If given an immoral order, what would be the basis of your decision to carry it out or not?

The basis of deciding whether to carry out an immoral order centers on the importance of individual moral judgment and ethical discernment. Relying on personal intuition reflects a commitment to an internal moral compass, which is vital in situations where orders may conflict with one's values or ethical standards. This approach emphasizes personal responsibility and the importance of integrity, suggesting that one must weigh the implications of actions and the possible harm they could cause against the guidelines of military conduct and personal ethics.

In military and naval contexts, following a hierarchical command structure can sometimes lead to situations where orders conflict with moral obligations. While other choices involve external validation or authority, prioritizing personal intuition recognizes the complexity of ethical dilemmas and endorses the idea that individuals are responsible for their actions, especially in cases where the order may be unjust or inhumane. This responsibility to act according to one's ethical beliefs is crucial, as it can uphold the values of honor and integrity that are foundational to military service.